I admit it I love Giuseppe Verdi and his operas. One of my favorites is DON CARLO. But it is the wrong version that I loved, the one in 4 acts and sung in Italian. Evidently people cannot get into the story without getting the pre-history, the Fontainebleau act. Just like all books must start with the beginning of the history and never as the action really starts. I don't think so.
Fontainebleau is naturally the beginning of how Elisabeth de Valois and Don Carlos, Infante of Spain meets (in the opera). It also gives the tenor more to sing and an additional duet with the soprano. But cut it out and now you have a pure opera that are much tighter bound dramatically. It starts in San Yuste monastery and ends there. All the cuts from the first 5 act opera in French and the work Giuseppe Verdi did made it much better and with a greater emotional impact. There is no need for a ballet, something that Paris Opera demanded. I don't think the Lacrymosa from Filip 2 was really needed. Giuseppe Verdi was a genious and he created the 4 act opera in Italian that is just perfect. In Italian the Spain sound more Spanish than in French. France and Spain was most of the time enemies, Italy and Spain was almost comrades. Of course, Italy did not exist as a country yet.
IL TROVATORE is another opera often called names. But it is perfect. If you read EL TROVADOR by Garcia Gutierrez and compare it to the opera. It is clear that the play has been tightened up just as it is mostly like Garcia Gutierrez wrote it. All talk about the inconsistency, the blame is with the playwright not the composer or librettist. Some say it had follow the story. Come on... it is not harder than most operas. Would they complain the layout if it was in a novel. Yes, they complain about Lord of the Rings. "How can I follow the story?". It is not played out in a linear way. Smart people get it. And it OPERA, it is the emotional impact that is important. Plays and books can be purely intellectual but opera need emotions. IL TROVATORE has emotions in spades.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Tuesday, 18 December 2012
Monday, 17 December 2012
December 17th: Carreras, Cura and Werther
I would love to see Carreras or Cura as Werther. Has Jose Cura ever sung Werther? He should....
Anyway on December 17, 1993 it was Christmas Gala with Josep Carreras and Karita Mattila in Oslo. It was great. On December 17, 2009 Jose Cura sang his songs from Argentina in Oslo's new Opera House. I want to hear another concert like that. On December 17, 2006 I saw Werther in Munich with Marcelo Alvarez and Sophie Koch. Great!!!
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Anyway on December 17, 1993 it was Christmas Gala with Josep Carreras and Karita Mattila in Oslo. It was great. On December 17, 2009 Jose Cura sang his songs from Argentina in Oslo's new Opera House. I want to hear another concert like that. On December 17, 2006 I saw Werther in Munich with Marcelo Alvarez and Sophie Koch. Great!!!
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
December 16: Going back home in pain
After a wonderful Carmen performance. I got sick that night. I was vomiting several times. I had pain in my stomach. So it was not a great night. I hardly slept.
Luckily I did manage to get home on Sunday without any more vomit. But I had still pains. While I still wanted someone to comfort me I got a phone call that was anything but, and that even after telling on SMS that I was sick and in bed early. I guess one does not hear others pain when one self is in pain as I guess my caller was.
My advise is listen and think what others might feel before one calls or sends sms.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Luckily I did manage to get home on Sunday without any more vomit. But I had still pains. While I still wanted someone to comfort me I got a phone call that was anything but, and that even after telling on SMS that I was sick and in bed early. I guess one does not hear others pain when one self is in pain as I guess my caller was.
My advise is listen and think what others might feel before one calls or sends sms.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
December 15: CARMEN by Bizet
Bizet: 19
19
Carmen 1985-05-03, 1991-05-06, 1992-11-07, 1998-10-21, 2000-02-05, 2000-06-25, 2002-05-15, 2002-06-22, 2002-06-23, 2002-06-26, 2002-09-29, 2003-06-27,2003-06-30, 2003-07-29, 2003-08-23, 2004-09-25, 2008-05-24, 2009-10-10, 2012-12-15
Carmen = Anita Rachvelishvili
Escamillo = Bastiaan Everink
Micaëla = Martina Welschenbach
Zuniga = Seth Carico
Moralès = Zheng Zhong Zhou
Dancairo = Jörg Schörner
Remendado = Matthew Pena
Frasquita = Hulkar Sabirova
Mercédès = Rachel Hauge
Jacques Lacombe, conductor
Regie (Søren Schuhmacher)
nach der Inszenierung von Peter Beauvais
Bühne, Kostüme - Pier Luigi Samaritani
Überarbeitung der Ausstattung - Norbert Bellen
Chöre - William Spaulding
Kinderchor - Dagmar Fiebach
I just saw my 19th Carmen in theatre. I loved it. And I just realized that this was my first and only Cura performance this year. That was unsuspected. But it was also my 99th to see José Cura. It was the 4th time I saw José Cura as Don José. First time at all with Anita Rachvelishvili. This CARMEN was special mostly because of her. Cura sang well, too. And I liked the old production.
12 years ago, or closer to 13 years ago I saw this production with Agnes Baltsa, Alberto Cupido, Michaela Kaune and Ludovic Tezier. It was a better production then without the new addiction.
The children is fighting as they singing in their angelic voices the soldiers coming and going. Now that is stupid and completely against the words they are singing. The children steals the hat from Don Jose and he has to play and plead to get it back. Now what are that about? And in the 4th act Carmen is now dress like a female matador and Frasquita and Mercedes has black dresses with wings. Black wings like death or something. The stets for Act 3 was from another Carmen production but that was unnoticeable.
Other than that it was great. It was a lot more dialogue than usual and in what I believe to be superb French.
I saw Carmen in Berlin in 2004 too, with Agnes Baltsa, Julian Gavin, Michaela Kaune and Laurent Naouri.
Anita Rachvellishvili was the perfect Carmen. Huge voice, great personality and great actress. José Cura did his best Don José ever. Then it was the question of Escamillo (Bastiaan Everink) and Micaëla (Martina Welschenbach). Bastiaan Everink looked the part but his singing was stiff. Martina Welschenbach looked very young, very thin, the first Micaela that looks 17. Great voice but I wanted more, not sure what.
Great CARMEN!
Friday, 14 December 2012
December 14: The day after and the day before
I have a headache. I had it yesterday too, but today I had to go from work early. Perhaps I worked to hard yesterday, too intense looking at the PC screen and then the movie. And today is also the day before. Before my travel to Berlin to see Carmen.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Besetzung
| Musikalische Leitung | Jacques Lacombe |
| Regie | Søren Schuhmacher |
| nach der Inszenierung von | Peter Beauvais |
| Bühne, Kostüme | Pier Luigi Samaritani |
| Überarbeitung der Ausstattung | Norbert Bellen |
| Chöre | William Spaulding |
| Kinderchor | Christian Lindhorst |
| Carmen | Anita Rachvelishvili |
| Frasquita | Hulkar Sabirova |
| Mercédès | Rachel Hauge |
| Micaëla | Martina Welschenbach |
| Don José | José Cura |
| Moralès | ZhengZhong Zhou |
| Zuniga | Seth Carico |
| Escamillo | Bastiaan Everink |
| Remendado | Matthew Pena |
| Dancairo | Jörg Schörner |
| Ein Bürger | Marek Picz |
| Andres | Sung Jin Kown |
| Chöre | Kinderchor der Deutschen Oper Berlin |
| Chor der Deutschen Oper Berlin | |
| Orchester | Orchester der Deutschen Oper Berlin |
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Thursday, 13 December 2012
December 13: The Hobbit & Santa Lucia
Two videos, The Hobbit trailer since I saw the movie today. The other Sancta Lucia with Jose Carreras and Sumi Jo because it is December 13, the day of Santa Lucia.
Wednesday, 12 December 2012
December 12: Meyerbeer and opera productions
12.12.12 but unfortunately at 12.12 I was busy at work with a pre-Christmas party so this blog post could not have been written at that time.
In May 1998 I saw LE PROPHETE by Giacomo Meyerbeer with Plácido Domingo as Jean and Agnes Baltsa as Fidès.
It was a Hans Neuenfels production. (Inszenierung - Hans Neuenfels, Bühnenbild und Kostüme - Reinhard von der Thannen, Choreinstudierung - Johannes Meister, Einstudierung der Tänze - Renato Zanella). I loved the opera and found the production not too disturbing. But it was certainly a modern production like those not loved by Facebooks Against Modern Opera Productions (AMOP). If La Cieca from Parterre Box could find something she did not hate about Meyerbeer and his operas then maybe she would have loved Wiener Staatsoper's LE PROPHETE.
But this shows the problem. What makes an opera great? Can we get an agreement here. (I doubt it). What makes an opera production great? It seem in vain to find an agreement here. Even what makes an opera production stinks, there can be NO agreement especially between AMOP and La Cieca. In reality this is bigger than 2 persons even such prominent and knowledgeable persons.
The dispute is about Regietheatre. Is it good or bad? Perhaps we can agree that we should be able to enjoy opera and not be just annoyed etc. by the directors maddening choices. Trouble is that we are all different.
The only thing I can just emphatically state is that LE PROPHETE is truly a wonderful opera by Giacomo Meyerbeer. So if you want one opera by Meyerbeer. This should be it.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
In May 1998 I saw LE PROPHETE by Giacomo Meyerbeer with Plácido Domingo as Jean and Agnes Baltsa as Fidès.
But this shows the problem. What makes an opera great? Can we get an agreement here. (I doubt it). What makes an opera production great? It seem in vain to find an agreement here. Even what makes an opera production stinks, there can be NO agreement especially between AMOP and La Cieca. In reality this is bigger than 2 persons even such prominent and knowledgeable persons.
The dispute is about Regietheatre. Is it good or bad? Perhaps we can agree that we should be able to enjoy opera and not be just annoyed etc. by the directors maddening choices. Trouble is that we are all different.
The only thing I can just emphatically state is that LE PROPHETE is truly a wonderful opera by Giacomo Meyerbeer. So if you want one opera by Meyerbeer. This should be it.
For reviews from my travels, see www.operaduetstravel.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


